November 1, 2007
By
JOSEPH TARTAKOFF
P-I REPORTER
The case of a B.C. investment
adviser accused of stealing up to
$30 million from his clients landed
in a Seattle courthouse this week,
as a trustee appointed by the man's
creditors questioned him in order to
determine what happened to some of
the money.
Over the course of more than two
years, the investment adviser, Ian
Thow persuaded his clients to give
him money to invest in securities
that did not exist, according to the
British Columbia Securities
Commission. Thow, who allegedly
lived a lavish lifestyle complete
with multiple jets and cars, is
accused of pocketing the money.
In a scathing report issued Oct. 16,
the Securities Commission said,
"This case represents one of the
most callous and audacious frauds
this province has seen."
One of Thow's lawyers, Larry
Feinstein, said his client "denies
all the allegations."
In 2005, while in negotiations with
his Canadian creditors, Thow, an
American citizen, moved to Seattle,
ending the talks and leading to his
automatic bankruptcy there, said
Michael Cheevers, the Canadian
trustee who was appointed to handle
the case.
In Washington, Thow started working
in the mortgage business -- at First
Magnus Financial and then, until
this week, at Flagstar Home Lending
in Bellevue, said Brad Ellis, the
Flagstar branch manager.
Ellis said that Thow had been hired
along with a group of loan officers
from First Magnus, which shut down
this summer. Ellis said Thursday
afternoon he was not sure how Thow's
history "slipped past" the hiring
process. He said that since Thow had
not originated any loans for
Flagstar, he was fired earlier this
week.
Earlier Thursday, a receptionist at
Flagstar transferred a call to Thow.
He declined to comment. In a
follow-up call, the receptionist
said he no longer worked there.
As part of the Canadian bankruptcy
proceedings, a U.S. bankruptcy judge
in Seattle, Philip Brandt, ordered
Thow on Monday to answer questions
under oath about his business and
financial affairs and to provide
financial documents because Thow had
"submitted unsatisfactory partial
answers" and had not provided any
documents in the past.
Cheevers said that while Thow is
legally bankrupt, "we have questions
as to his financial situation at the
moment."
"Mr. Thow has very significant
creditors and (a) significant amount
of money went through his control
and we are trying to establish
whether it's accounted for,"
Cheevers said. "The role of the
trustee is to obtain all the assets
that are available for distribution
and distribute them among the
creditors."
Feinstein, Thow's bankruptcy lawyer,
said that in court, Thow entered a
"wide-ranging" deposition, although
neither Feinstein nor Cheevers would
comment on what Thow said because
his deposition is under seal.
Feinstein said Thow's bankruptcy is
"pending in Canada, and they just
came down from Canada to the U.S. to
talk to Mr. Thow, and they did and
there's nothing left pending here."
"He was an investment broker.
Investments go bad," said Feinstein,
who added that his client was
voluntarily cooperating with the
bankruptcy proceedings. "We don't
have the money."
Cheevers said the next step is that
"we are likely to have more
questions."
"We are looking for funds," he said.
"There is never any end to the
questions you can ask." In addition,
he said, "The police authorities in
Canada are investigating his
affairs."
Thow's clients say they were
betrayed. Impressed by Thow's
apparent wealth -- he told clients
he owned two private jets, a
helicopter, two Mercedes and a
56-foot yacht -- and his charm and
promises of lofty returns, clients
gave Thow millions to invest
ostensibly for short-term
construction loans and preferred
shares of the National Commercial
Bank Jamaica Limited. Often, the
clients would mortgage their homes
or borrow money to boost their
investments, according to the
British Columbia Securities
Commission's findings.
"He had all the buzzwords. He was a
big deal," said Brad Goodwin, a
former pilot who lives on a
disability income, whose family
invested more than a million dollars
with Thow. "It started to really
make money. Every time we looked it
went up."
Goodwin, who lives in Richmond,
B.C., said Thow owes his family $1.2
million.
"He took our life savings, and I
have no future to get it back now,"
he said.
Kirk Wong and his wife, Krista
Kleven, invested about $250,000 with
Thow -- purportedly in the Jamaican
bank.
"We gave him $50,000 checks and
money whenever he wanted it because
we thought we were doing so well and
we could see how well he was doing,"
said Wong, a 48- year-old commercial
fisherman, who lives on a pension
since being injured.
He said that when he realized that
the investment did not actually
exist, "then we went to the
authorities."
P-I reporter Joseph Tartakoff can
be reached at 206-448-8293 or
joetartakoff@seattlepi.com
|